Post by Host Lex on Jul 29, 2013 20:32:29 GMT -5
ALEX: 28/40
Originality/Creativity: 9/15. I liked the idea of casting parties and behind the scenes stuff, that was creative.
Entertainment: 10/15. Started off pretty entertaining. The Michael being killed plot came outta no where and was bizarre haha. I thought Kim would be his motivation to get back and shape and appear on the show again, but the Michael murder was a bit off I thought
Grammar: 9/10. No noticeable errors. Just one point shy of perfect because the formatting wasn't interesting
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CANDICE: 33/40
Originality/Creativity: 13/15. I loved that she went into the mental side effects that the game could have. Writing it as if she was having post traumatic stress disorder was pretty creative.
Entertainment: 12/15. I lol'd a few times. I liked the triggers that flashed her back to her season, like the mention of JOHN. That part was great. And her competitive nature coming out as it did in her original season.
Grammar: 8/10. I caught a couple of mistakes, but nothing big.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CHASE: 29/40
Originality/Creativity: 12/15. The idea of doing it as the pre-season interview that Probst does each season is creative. I liked that. Definitely pretty different.
Entertainment: 8/15. I thought some jokes were good while others missed tbh. The commercial was funny
Grammar: 9/10. I noticed a few grammar mistakes, but he told me it was meant to be how that person would be talking since it's interview style. His nice format kinda evened that out to a 9 for me
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
KIM: 30/40
Originality/Creativity: 11/15. Nothing particularly unique about it, though I did like the public's perception of her angle. That was probably the strongest part
Entertainment: 10/15. The two Rory parts were the funniest. I lol'd at his phone call to her. Apart from that, there wasn't too much that did it for as far as entertainment goes.
Grammar: 9/10. Well written with few mistakes. One off from perfect because of the uninteresting formatting.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIKI: 19/40
Originality/Creativity: 8/15. Her approach was pretty typical. Nothing stood out as being very different or unique to me.
Entertainment: 7/15. Full of 'miki humor'. Lot's of cunt goddess sex drug shit. Not my personal favorite tbh. It was pretty long and I kind of wanted it to be over fairly early. It had its moments though
Grammar: 4/10. Not great. Seemed like she wrote it all in one go without checking back on anything. A lot of mistakes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
SYDNEY: 32/40
Originality/Creativity: 12/15. Was a bit of a mix of a few different people's stories, but that's just because of the order I read them in. It had its creative moments.
Entertainment: 11/15. The post traumatic stress stuff was good here too. Like her thinking her baby would turn on her the second it was born, and her thoughts on her actual Jury compared to her SI Jury. Overall I thought it was fairly funny
Grammar: 9/10. Would've been a 10 because of the above average formatting, but she had enough mistakes to bump it down for me.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
VEE: 28/40
Originality/Creativity: 10/15. lol another pregnancy one. We got a few of those! This one didn't really offer up anything too new compared to the rest.
Entertainment: 9/15. Same pregnancy/sex/dildo jokes as Miki's, but they worked better here I think. The shorter length helped with that. It was entertaining enough.
Grammar: 9/10. Same as the rest really. Few mistakes but no thrilling formatting.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originality/Creativity: 9/15. I liked the idea of casting parties and behind the scenes stuff, that was creative.
Entertainment: 10/15. Started off pretty entertaining. The Michael being killed plot came outta no where and was bizarre haha. I thought Kim would be his motivation to get back and shape and appear on the show again, but the Michael murder was a bit off I thought
Grammar: 9/10. No noticeable errors. Just one point shy of perfect because the formatting wasn't interesting
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CANDICE: 33/40
Originality/Creativity: 13/15. I loved that she went into the mental side effects that the game could have. Writing it as if she was having post traumatic stress disorder was pretty creative.
Entertainment: 12/15. I lol'd a few times. I liked the triggers that flashed her back to her season, like the mention of JOHN. That part was great. And her competitive nature coming out as it did in her original season.
Grammar: 8/10. I caught a couple of mistakes, but nothing big.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
CHASE: 29/40
Originality/Creativity: 12/15. The idea of doing it as the pre-season interview that Probst does each season is creative. I liked that. Definitely pretty different.
Entertainment: 8/15. I thought some jokes were good while others missed tbh. The commercial was funny
Grammar: 9/10. I noticed a few grammar mistakes, but he told me it was meant to be how that person would be talking since it's interview style. His nice format kinda evened that out to a 9 for me
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
KIM: 30/40
Originality/Creativity: 11/15. Nothing particularly unique about it, though I did like the public's perception of her angle. That was probably the strongest part
Entertainment: 10/15. The two Rory parts were the funniest. I lol'd at his phone call to her. Apart from that, there wasn't too much that did it for as far as entertainment goes.
Grammar: 9/10. Well written with few mistakes. One off from perfect because of the uninteresting formatting.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
MIKI: 19/40
Originality/Creativity: 8/15. Her approach was pretty typical. Nothing stood out as being very different or unique to me.
Entertainment: 7/15. Full of 'miki humor'. Lot's of cunt goddess sex drug shit. Not my personal favorite tbh. It was pretty long and I kind of wanted it to be over fairly early. It had its moments though
Grammar: 4/10. Not great. Seemed like she wrote it all in one go without checking back on anything. A lot of mistakes
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
SYDNEY: 32/40
Originality/Creativity: 12/15. Was a bit of a mix of a few different people's stories, but that's just because of the order I read them in. It had its creative moments.
Entertainment: 11/15. The post traumatic stress stuff was good here too. Like her thinking her baby would turn on her the second it was born, and her thoughts on her actual Jury compared to her SI Jury. Overall I thought it was fairly funny
Grammar: 9/10. Would've been a 10 because of the above average formatting, but she had enough mistakes to bump it down for me.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------
VEE: 28/40
Originality/Creativity: 10/15. lol another pregnancy one. We got a few of those! This one didn't really offer up anything too new compared to the rest.
Entertainment: 9/15. Same pregnancy/sex/dildo jokes as Miki's, but they worked better here I think. The shorter length helped with that. It was entertaining enough.
Grammar: 9/10. Same as the rest really. Few mistakes but no thrilling formatting.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------